Key Lime Pie Lady is one of Islamorada's well-regarded neighbourhood bakeries — a place built on the daily rhythm of fresh bread, pastries, and reliable quality. 4/5 from 10 reviews — a bakery that regulars return to for the basics done well. Expect Fresh Bread, Pastries, Cakes, Cookies, Sandwiches at the counter.
What to Expect
A visit to Key Lime Pie Lady in Islamorada is a neighbourhood bakery experience. Expect a glass counter showcasing the day's bake — loaves of bread cooling on racks, trays of pastries lined up by mid-morning, and a steady stream of regulars who know exactly what they want. The best items tend to sell out early, so arriving before noon gives you the full selection. Counter service is standard; most bakeries do not take reservations for walk-in visits.
Bakeries in Islamorada
From heritage bakeries serving generations of families to a new wave of sourdough and viennoiserie specialists, Islamorada's 0+ bakeries cover everything that United States's bread culture is known for. Expect strong local traditions alongside internationally influenced technique.
50 Best Bakeries Rating
Google Rating
Based on 10 reviews
Your Rating
Drinks & Specialties
Editorial Recognition
Key Lime Pie Lady has earned editorial recognition from 50 Best Bakeries (#5 in Islamorada). Based on 10 verified Google reviews, it maintains a solid 4/5 rating.
Location
Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Key Lime Pie Lady specialise in?
Key Lime Pie Lady is a bakery in Islamorada, United States, known for Fresh Bread, Pastries, Cakes, Cookies, and more. The bakery format means you can expect a focus on fresh bread, pastries, and daily bakes.
What is the rating of Key Lime Pie Lady?
Key Lime Pie Lady holds a Google rating of 4/5 based on 10 verified reviews. Our editorial rating is 4.1/5, which factors in consistency, baking quality, and regional standing.
Where is Key Lime Pie Lady located?
Key Lime Pie Lady is located in Islamorada, United States. You can find directions and the exact location on Google Maps.
When is the best time to visit Key Lime Pie Lady?
For the freshest selection, visit Key Lime Pie Lady shortly after opening — typically between 7am and 10am. Popular items sell through by midday, so early visits give you the best choice. Weekend mornings tend to be busiest.
Does Key Lime Pie Lady take orders or reservations?
Most bakerys operate as walk-in only with counter service. For celebration cakes, custom orders, or large pastry orders, contact Key Lime Pie Lady directly to arrange in advance. Some bakeries also offer pre-orders for whole loaves.
How does Key Lime Pie Lady compare to other bakeries in Islamorada?
With a 4/5 rating from 10 reviews, Key Lime Pie Lady holds a strong position in Islamorada. Our ranking considers Google reviews, editorial recognition, and baking quality to give a balanced picture of the Islamorada bakery scene.
